
Black Friday is November 27. The pitch is the same every year: buy now, save big. But this year a lot of us are trying to give a good Christmas with less money.
I used to love Black Friday but now I celebrate Green Friday instead. It’s on the same day as Black Friday, but almost nobody knows about it. It’s a movement to shop differently on the biggest shopping day of the year: secondhand, local, fewer impulse buys. It’s also a better way to save.
Shoppers plan to spend $879 on gifts this year, down 21% from last year, according to a NerdWallet survey conducted by The Harris Poll. In a Penny Hoarder survey, 77% of Americans say rising prices are changing how they buy gifts, and 17% are still carrying debt from last year’s holidays.
Where Black Friday “savings” go
Two things quietly eat the discount.
The first is buy now, pay later, the “split it into 4 payments” button at checkout. Nearly 2 in 5 holiday shoppers plan to use it this year, according to NerdWallet. And more than a third of them already expect to miss a payment or pay late. Miss one, and late fees or interest can wipe out what you saved on the sale.
The second is returns. Retailers expect shoppers to send back 17% of holiday sales, according to NRF and Happy Returns. That’s money and time spent on things nobody wanted. Returned clothes don’t always get resold either. Research from Equal Ventures, cited by Retail Dive, estimates more than 11% of returned apparel ends up in a landfill.
Five ways to spend less and still make Christmas good
- Buy gifts secondhand. A vintage jacket or a one-of-a-kind find feels more personal than whatever’s trending, and it usually costs less. You’re in good company: the U.S. secondhand clothing market grew nearly four times faster than the overall clothing market in 2025, according to ThredUp’s 2026 Resale Report.
- Give a plan instead of a package. Dinner, a class, concert tickets or a day trip. There’s nothing to wrap and nothing to return, and it’s the gift people actually remember.
- Host a swap. Get friends together before the holiday parties and trade clothes, accessories or even gifts you know you won’t use. Everyone leaves with something new to them, for free.
- 4. Shop small and local. Some of the best gifts come from independent designers and local makers: people who sew, knit, upcycle or design one-of-a-kind pieces in small batches. Check holiday markets, pop-ups, consignment shops and neighborhood boutiques. When you buy in person, you skip shipping costs and packaging, and you never have to deal with a return label. Your money stays in your community and goes straight to the person who made the piece, not a warehouse. And the day after Green Friday is Small Business Saturday, November 28, so make it a full weekend.
- Pick one number and stick to it. Set your budget before you open a single sale email. Use money you have, not a payment plan.
I’ve seen what a swap can do

This fall I ran The Ultimate Halloween Swap. People dropped off costumes they were done with and took home a new-to-them one for free. Thousands of costumes came in across 8 locations, so those costumes nobody had to buy and nobody threw out.
We’ve also hosted swaps at the Net Zero Conference and at Heal the Bay’s Aquarium, and every time people leave with something they love without spending a dollar.
There are more swaps coming. If you want to bring one to your community, donate clothes or volunteer at the next one, follow me on Instagram. That’s where I post the dates first.
The same idea works for Christmas. You don’t need a bigger budget for a good holiday. You need a different plan.
Your Green Friday challenge
On November 27, buy one gift secondhand or skip one purchase you’d probably return. Post it and tag me @lexysilverstein. I’ll share my favorites.
Find your Green Friday gifts near you
I’ve mapped out secondhand and vintage shops in cities across the country and in London. Follow me on Instagram for every new guide, and start your gift list here:
Los Angeles
- Silver Lake, Echo Park & Atwater Village
- Downtown LA: Arts District & Fashion District
- Burbank & Magnolia Village

Southern California

New York City

Philadelphia

Washington, DC

Chicago

Nashville

Florida

London

Love, Lexy

![Lexy Silverstein [holding secondhand holiday gifts / describe photo] for Green Friday](https://lexysilverstein.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/image.png)
